🧾 Understanding GSTN Advisory on Table 8A vs 8C Mismatch for FY 2023-24
The GSTN Advisory No. 557 (dated December 09, 2024) highlights a critical issue: the mismatch in Table 8A and 8C of the annual return (Form GSTR-9) for FY 2023-24. This discrepancy arises due to changes in the auto-population of data, creating confusion for taxpayers.
🔍 Why Does the Table 8A and 8C Mismatch Occur?
According to Notification No. 12/2024 (July 10, 2024) and Notification No. 20/2024 (October 8, 2024), the following changes apply for FY 2023-24:
- Table 8A (Total ITC on inward supplies) is now auto-populated from GSTR-2B instead of GSTR-2A.
- Table 8C (ITC availed in subsequent FY) must be filled manually.
This shift from GSTR-2A to GSTR-2B impacts the numbers:
- FY 2022-23: Table 8A used data from GSTR-2A.
- FY 2023-24: Table 8A uses data from GSTR-2B, causing potential over-reporting for FY 2022-23 and under-reporting for FY 2023-24.
📌 Key Issues Highlighted by GSTN
- Inflated ITC in Table 8A:
Due to GSTR-2B, FY 2023-24 data may reflect excess credit from FY 2022-23. - Lower-than-Expected ITC in Table 8C:
Manual entries in Table 8C might not capture delayed ITC claims accurately. - Taxpayer Confusion:
Many taxpayers reported discrepancies through tickets raised on the GST portal.
⚖️ Relevant Case Laws and Implications
Several legal rulings address ITC discrepancies:
- Madhya Pradesh HC Ruling – Courts have stressed the need for clarity in ITC reporting to avoid undue penalties.
- Supreme Court in Calcutta Club Ltd. – Emphasized that procedural mismatches shouldn’t impact legitimate credit claims.
✅ Steps to Handle Table 8A and 8C Mismatch
Step | Action |
---|---|
1 | Verify GSTR-2B auto-populated values in Table 8A. |
2 | Manually reconcile ITC for Table 8C. |
3 | Cross-check previous FY credits to avoid errors. |
4 | Document any discrepancies and raise queries. |
📢 Conclusion
This advisory underscores the importance of accurate reconciliation between Tables 8A and 8C in Form GSTR-9. Staying updated and ensuring manual checks can help avoid compliance issues.